Keepers 2010 Keepers & Keeper Points
| Team | Matt | Flava | Buxton | Pinstripe | Scrantonicity | Freeze | Southpaws | MVB | Jarsh | S-Man | Mendoza | Kryptonite |
| Tot. Pts | 7 | 2 | 7 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 7 | 6 | 2 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
| Player 1 | Hanley Ramirez 3 |
Victor Martinez 0 |
Miguel Cabrera 5 |
Derek Jeter 0 |
Albert Pujols 2 |
Kendry Morales 0 |
David Wright 4 |
Pablo Sandoval 0 |
Joe Mauer 0 |
Chase Utley 4 |
Ben Zobrist 0 |
Jose Reyes 4 |
| Player 2 | Justin Morneau 0 |
Adrian Gonzalez 1 |
Aaron Hill 0 |
C.C. Sabathia 2 |
Ryan Howard 4 |
Dustin Pedroia 1 |
Chone Figgins 1 |
Evan Longoria 1 |
Zack Greinke 0 |
Joey Votto 0 |
Tim Lincecum 1 |
Yovanni Gallardo 0 |
| Player 3 | Ian Kinsler 1 |
Ichiro Suzuki 1 |
Prince Fielder 2 |
Alex Rodriguez 0 |
Troy Tulowitzki 0 |
Curtis Granderson 0 |
Felix Hernandez 1 |
Matt Holliday 3 |
Dan Haren 0 |
Roy Halladay 1 |
Matt Kemp 1 |
Ryan Braun 2 |
| Player 4 | Aramis Ramirez 2 |
Ryan Zimmerman 0 |
Josh Johnson 0 |
Robinson Cano 0 |
Carl Crawford 1 |
Kevin Youkilis 1 |
Shane Victorino 1 |
Brian Roberts 2 |
Justin Upton 0 |
Jayson Werth 0 |
Mark Reynolds 0 |
Ricky Nolasco 0 |
| Player 5 | Jacoby Ellsbury 1 |
Jon Lester 0 |
Tommy Hanson 0 |
Mark Teixeira 2 |
Brandon Phillips 0 |
Clayton Kershaw 0 |
Torii Hunter 0 |
Justin Verlander 0 |
Nick Markakis 2 |
Adam Wainwright 0 |
Grady Sizemore 4 |
Brian McCann 1 |
2009 Keepers & Keeper Points
| Team | McMeatmen | Scott/Matt | Buxton | Amato | Scrantonicity | Freeze | Southpaws | MVB | Josh | S-Man | Mendoza | Kryptonite |
| Tot. Pts | 6 | 5 | 7 | 6 | 7 | 6 | 6 | 7 | 7 | 7 | 6 | 5 |
| Player 1 | Hanley Ramirez 2 |
Manny Ramirez 5 |
Alfonso Soriano 5 |
Johan Santana 5 |
Albert Pujols 1 |
Miguel Cabrera 4 |
Vladimir Guerrero 5 |
Jimmy Rollins 4 |
David Wright 3 |
Chase Utley 3 |
Carlos Beltran 5 |
Jose Reyes 3 |
| Player 2 | Lance Berkman 3 |
Adrian Gonzalez 0 |
Jake Peavy 1 |
CC Sabathia 1 |
Ryan Howard 3 |
Brandon Webb 1 |
Dan Haren 1 |
Evan Longoria 0 |
Josh Hamilton 0 |
Carlos Lee 3 |
Tim Lincecum 0 |
Mark Teixeira 1 |
| Player 3 | Ian Kinsler 0 |
Ichiro Suzuki 0 |
Prince Fielder 1 |
Mariano Rivera 0 |
Cole Hamels 2 |
Russell Martin 1 |
Felix Hernandez 0 |
Matt Holliday 2 |
Grady Sizemore 3 |
Roy Halladay 0 |
Matt Kemp 0 |
Ryan Braun 1 |
| Player 4 | Aramis Ramirez 1 |
Dan Uggla 0 |
Carlos Quentin 0 |
Jermaine Dye 0 |
Carl Crawford 0 |
Kevin Youkilis 0 |
Chad Billingsley 0 |
Brian Roberts 1 |
BJ Upton 1 |
Jason Bay 0 |
Jonathan Papelbon 1 |
Chipper Jones 0 |
| Player 5 | Jacoby Ellsbury 0 |
James Shields 0 |
Dustin Pedroia 0 |
Joba Chamberlain 0 |
Nick Markakis 1 |
Joakim Soria 0 |
Chone Figgins 0 |
Chris Davis 0 |
Geovany Soto 0 |
Josh Beckett 1 |
Shane Victorino 0 |
Brian McCann 0 |
2008 Keepers & Keeper Points
| Team | Josh | Freeze | Meatmen | Matt/Scott | Kryptonite | Amato | Mendoza | Southpaws | Scrantonicity | S-Man | Buxton | MVB |
| Tot. Pts | 5 | 5 | 4 | 7 | 5 | 6 | 3 | 6 | 3 | 6 | 7 | 7 |
| Player 1 | Justin Morneau 1 |
Brandon Webb 0 |
Hanley Ramirez 1 |
John Smoltz 1 |
Eric Bedard 0 |
Scott Kazmir 0 |
Lance Berkman 2 |
Vladimir Guerrero 4 |
Cole Hamels 1 |
Carlos Beltran 4 |
Johan Santana 4 |
Alex Rodriguez 4 |
| Player 2 | B.J. Upton 0 |
Miguel Cabrera 3 |
Chris Young (P) 0 |
Victor Martinez 2 |
Jose Reyes 2 |
Alfonso Soriano 4 |
Carlos Guillen 1 |
Chase Utley 2 |
Albert Pujols 0 |
Chone Figgins 0 |
Jake Peavy 0 |
C.C. Sabathia 0 |
| Player 3 | Prince Fielder 0 |
Travis Hafner 2 |
Aramis Ramirez 0 |
Trevor Hoffman 0 |
Mark Teixeira 0 |
Matt Holliday 1 |
Francisco Cordero 0 |
Takashi Saito 0 |
Ryan Howard 2 |
Carlos Lee 2 |
Magglio Ordonez 0 |
Jimmy Rollins 3 |
| Player 4 | Grady Sizemore 2 |
Troy Tulowitzki 0 |
Joe Nathan 2 |
Manny Ramirez 4 |
Ryan Braun 0 |
Curtis Granderson 0 |
Jonathan Papelbon 0 |
Dan Haren 0 |
Brandon Philips 0 |
Josh Beckett 0 |
Francisco Rodriguez 0 |
Alex Rios 0 |
| Player 5 | David Wright 2 |
Russell Martin 0 |
J.J. Putz 1 |
Torii Hunter 0 |
Bobby Abreu 3 |
Robinson Cano 1 |
Ryan Zimmerman 0 |
Garrett Atkins 0 |
Nick Markakis 0 |
Eric Byrnes 0 |
David Ortiz 3 |
Brian Roberts 0 |
2007 Keepers & Keeper Points
| Team | Josh | Scrantonicity | Freeze | Meatmen | Buxton |
Southpaws |
Amato |
Matt/Scott |
MVB |
S-Man | Kryptonite |
Mendoza |
| Tot. Pts | 7 | 4 | 4 | 2 | 7 | 6 | 7 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 3 | 6 |
| Player 1 | Miguel Tejada 3 |
Ryan Howard 1 |
Miguel Cabrera 2 |
Hanley Ramirez 0 |
Johan Santana 3 |
Vladimir Guerrero 3 |
Derek Jeter 2 |
Manny Ramirez 3 |
David Ortiz 2 |
Carlos Beltran 3 |
Jose Reyes 1 |
Alfonso Soriano 3 |
| Player 2 | Roy Halladay 3 |
David Wright 1 |
Travis Hafner 1 |
Jermaine Dye 0 |
Ichiro Suzuki 2 |
Chase Utley 1 |
Mariano Rivera 2 |
Paul Konerko 1 |
Justin Morneau 0 |
Carlos Zambrano 2 |
Andruw Jones 1 |
Lance Berkman 1 |
| Player 3 | Vernon Wells 0 |
Carl Crawford 2 |
Chris Carpenter 1 |
Nick Swisher 0 |
Derek Lee 1 |
John Lackey 1 |
Robinson Cano 0 |
Victor Martinez 1 |
Roy Oswalt 2 |
Jason Bay 1 |
Felix Hernandez 1 |
Bobby Abreu 2 |
| Player 4 | Grady Sizemore 1 |
Ben Sheets 0 |
B.J. Ryan 0 |
Michael Young 2 |
Rafael Furcal 0 |
Hideki Matsui 1 |
Joe Mauer 0 |
Troy Glaus 0 |
Jimmy Rollins 2 |
Carlos Lee 1 |
Cole Hamels 0 |
Carlos Guillen 0 |
| Player 5 | Jason Schmidt 0 |
Delmon Young 0 |
Jeremy Bonderman 0 |
J.J. Putz 0 |
Joe Nathan 1 |
Johnny Damon 0 |
Alex Rodriguez 3 |
John Smoltz 0 |
Matt Holliday 0 |
Jim Thome 0 |
Brian McCann 0 |
Juan Pierre 0 |
2006 Keepers & Keeper Points
| Team | Josh | Scrantonicity | Freeze | Meatmen | Buxton |
Southpaws |
Amato |
Matt/Scott |
MVB |
S-Man | Kryptonite |
Mendoza |
| Tot. Pts | 7 | 3 | 1 | 4 | 3 | 1 | 6 | 0 (Expansion) | 4 | 5 | 2 | 6 |
| Player 1 | Manny Ramirez 2 |
Albert Pujols 2 |
Travis Hafner 0 |
Barry Bonds 2 |
Johan Santana 2 |
Brad Lidge 1 |
Alex Rodriguez 2 |
Randy Johnson 0 |
David Ortiz 1 |
Vladimir Guerrero 2 |
Pedro Martinez 2 |
Todd Helton 2 |
| Player 2 | Roy Halladay 2 |
Miguel Cabrera 1 |
Chris Carpenter 0 |
Michael Young 1 |
Ichiro Suzuki 1 |
Hideki Matsui 0 |
Gary Sheffield 2 |
Jhonny Peralta 0 |
Roy Oswalt 1 |
Carlos Beltran 2 |
Adam Dunn 0 |
Alfonso Soriano 2 |
| Player 3 | Miguel Tejada 2 |
David Wright 0 |
Bartolo Colon 0 |
Mark Teixeira 1 |
Richie Sexson 0 |
John Lackey 0 |
Derek Jeter 1 |
Victor Martinez 0 |
Aramis Ramirez 1 |
Carlos Zambrano 1 |
Felix Hernandez 0 |
Francisco Rodriguez 1 |
| Player 4 | Carlos Delgado 1 |
Ryan Howard 0 |
Chase Utley 0 |
Ken Griffey Jr. 0 |
Derek Lee 0 |
B.J. Ryan 0 |
Mariano Rivera 1 |
Paul Konerko 0 |
Jimmy Rollins 1 |
Jason Bay 0 |
Andruw Jones 0 |
Bobby Abreu 1 |
| Player 5 | Rich Harden 0 |
Rickie Weeks 0 |
Carl Crawford 1 |
Jeff Kent 0 |
Joe Nathan 0 |
Billy Wagner 0 |
Chone Figgins 0 |
Grady Sizemore 0 |
Jake Peavy 0 |
Carlos Lee 0 |
Jose Reyes 0 |
Lance Berkman 0 |
2005 Keepers & Keeper Points
| Team | Josh | Scrantonicity | Freeze | Tony |
Buxton |
Southpaws |
Amato |
MVB |
S-Man | Kryptonite |
Mendoza | |
| Tot. Pts | 3 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 0 (Expansion) | 3 | 3 | 3 | |
| Player 1 | Manny Ramirez 2 |
Albert Pujols 1 |
Jason Schmidt 1 |
Barry Bonds 1 |
Johan Santana 1 |
Brad Lidge 0 |
Alex Rodriguez 1 |
David Ortiz 0 |
Vladimir Guerrero 1 |
Pedro Martinez 1 |
Todd Helton 1 |
|
| Player 2 | Roy Halladay 1 |
Miguel Cabrera 0 |
Hank Blalock 0 |
Michael Young 0 |
Ichiro Suzuki 0 |
Carlos Zambrano 0 |
Gary Sheffield 1 |
Roy Oswalt 0 |
Carlos Beltran 1 |
Randy Johnson 1 |
Alfonso Soriano 1 |
|
| Player 3 | Aubrey Huff 0 |
Curt Schilling 1 |
Sammy Sosa 0 |
Mark Teixeira 0 |
Mark Prior 1 |
Marcus Giles 0 |
Derek Jeter 0 |
Aramis Ramirez 0 |
Kerry Wood 1 |
Miguel Tejada 1 |
Francisco Rodriguez 0 |
|
| Player 4 | Carlos Delgado 0 |
Jim Thome 1 |
Magglio Ordonez 0 |
Tim Hudson 1 |
Nomar Garciaparra 1 |
Ivan Rodriguez 0 |
Mariano Rivera 0 |
Jimmy Rollins 0 |
Scott Rolen 0 |
Victor Martinez 0 |
Bobby Abreu 0 |
|
| Player 5 | Adrian Beltre 0 |
Carl Crawford 0 |
Carlos Guillen 0 |
Moises Alou 0 |
Eric Chavez 0 |
Melvin Mora 0 |
Roger Clemens 0 |
Javy Lopez 0 |
Oliver Perez 0 |
Ben Sheets 0 |
Eric Gagne 1 |
2004 Keepers & Keeper Points
| Team | Josh | Scrantonicity | Freeze | Tony |
Buxton |
Southpaws |
Amato |
S-Man | Kryptonite |
Mendoza | ||
| Tot. Pts | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Player 1 | Manny Ramirez 0 |
Albert Pujols 0 |
Jason Schmidt 0 |
Barry Bonds 0 |
Johan Santana 0 |
Jeff Kent 0 |
Roy Halladay 0 |
Vladimir Guerrero 0 |
Pedro Martinez 0 |
Todd Helton 0 |
||
| Player 2 | Miguel Tejada 0 |
Jim Thome 0 |
John Smoltz 0 |
Tim Hudson 0 |
Alex Rodriguez 0 |
Randy Johnson 0 |
Gary Sheffield 0 |
Nomar Garciaparra 0 |
Mark Prior 0 |
Alfonso Soriano 0 |
||
| Player 3 | Hideo Nomo 0 |
Curt Schilling 0 |
Bret Boone 0 |
Keith Foulke 0 |
Magglio Ordonez 0 |
Carlos Beltran 0 |
Mike Mussina 0 |
Kerry Wood 0 |
Mark Mulder 0 |
Eric Gagne 0 |
